There are several possible defenses an experienced defense attorney may argue against a theft charge in Texas. The defense, or defenses, a defense attorney chooses will depend upon the circumstances of the case.
The following is not a complete list of potential defenses to a theft charge. However, these are some of the more commonly used and successful.
- Honest mistake. The defendant honestly believed that the property belonged to them at the time the incident occurred, and can provide evidence proving this. This defense is a possibility when the defendant borrowed the item but forgot to return it.
- It may also work if a defendant left an item in their purse or shopping bag by accident. Honest mistake is a defense to theft as there is no intent to steal. A key element in theft crimes.
- Returned property. Although returning property may not result in a dismissal of theft charges, it may help a defendant’s case. Returning property may cause a judge to look more favorably on the defendant and agree to a reduced sentence.
- Lack of False Pretenses. Lack of false pretenses only applies to certain theft crimes. For instance, when the defendant is accused of misrepresenting themselves to commit theft, but there is no supporting evidence of misrepresentation. Lack of false pretenses may be used to have the charges dismissed.
- Entrapment. In a theft crime, entrapment is when someone uses an innocent person to commit the theft crime with the intent of getting the innocent person arrested and prosecuted. A successful entrapment defense can result in the dismissal of theft charges.
- Duress. If the defendant was forced under threat of bodily harm to themselves or their family, then the theft crime was committed under duress. Duress in an effective defense to theft charges.
There are other defenses for theft crimes in Texas called offense-specific defenses. This means these defenses only apply to a specific theft crime not theft crimes in general.
Theft crimes with offense-specific defenses include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Tampering with serial numbers. Defenses to this charge are as follows:
- The property owner gave their consent for the defendant to make the changes;
- The defendant was a peace officer acting within the scope of their duties; or
- The defendant was an employee or agent of the Texas Department of Transportation or Texas Department of Motor Vehicles and acting within the scope of their duties in full compliance of department rules.
- Vehicle rental violations. The defense to a vehicle rental violation is the defendant provided a post-dated check or similar sight order to pay for the vehicle rental. However, the rental company presented the check or sight order for payment prior to the date on the check or sight order.
To find out if there is an offense-specific defense to a Texas theft crime, contact an experienced theft crime defense attorney in San Antonio.